By On sábado, março 11 th, 2023 · tetraphosphordecaoxid formel · In

The Oneidas, under pressure from state and federal governments, were uprooted from New York in the 1820s and 1830s. There was also a succession of set-backs and defeats in the courts. Popularly known as "Indian Princess Wynnogene," Kellogg was the voice of the Oneidas and Haudenosaunee people in national and international forums. Kellogg's outspoken criticism and activities earned her powerful adversaries. Laura Cornelius Kellogg was descended from a line of influential Oneida political leaders who had been heavily involved in planning and governing the new reservation. She is best known for her extraordinary . [53] According to Kellogg, homogeneity, or of the same kind or nature, was the most important aspect of the plan. Soon after the loss of her clan mother, Kellogg decided to return to the traditional practices of her tribe. The Bureau approved the plan, and Kellogg actively pursued loans from 1919 to 1924. Laura Cornelius Kellogg ("Minnie") ("Wynnogene") (September 10, 1880 1947), was an Oneida leader, author, orator, activist and visionary. "Wherever she has gone, society has simply 'ovated' her, and were she to remain in England long, she would doubtless be the leader of the circle all her own. Kellogg believed that the Bureau of Indian Affairs could play a different role, that of guarantor of sovereignty and protector of Native peoples from grafters and petty state politics. [37] Charles E. Dagenett had the chair, with Emma Johnson, Rosa LaFlesche and Fayette Avery McKenzie in attendance. Thread starter TOP; Start date Yesterday at 12:05 AM; 110. Kellogg's campaign in New York was fraught with problems, and there was Critical to her vision was the reinstatement of land and she led efforts to restore land to the Haudenosaunee Confederacy as a whole, in keeping with her efforts to restore traditional social structures from the clan level to the whole Confederacy. The Lolomi plan would allow the property of the tribes and individuals to be used for "education, health, and commercial development expenses".[52]. After the Society's Columbus meeting in 1911, the New York Tribune hailed Cornelius as a scholar, a social worker, "one of the moving spirits in the new American Indian Association, " and "a woman of rare intellectual gifts. [76] They collected money from Iroquois in New York, Oklahoma, Wisconsin, Ontario and Quebec, stating it would be used to claim up to eighteen million acres of land in New York and Pennsylvania. The type of industry would be geared to local needs, skills, and the stage of development of the particular community. After their meeting in Washington, Chief Smith invited Minnie and Chester to implement and manage a Lolomi Plan for the Nighthawk Keetoowah. In contrast to many of her contemporaries, Kellogg focused on restoring traditional governance and lands for the Haudenosaunee at a time when assimilation and the breakup of reservations were generally seen as the best path for advancing Native American interests. Through all the world you are mighty righter of wrongs, the savior of oppressed peoples. Philip J. Deloria, "Four Thousand Invitations", SAIL 25.2/AIQ 37.3 Summer 2013, P.28. In 1919, Kellogg saw an opportunity to develop the Lolomi plan on the Oneida Indian Reservation when the Bureau of Indian Affairs closed the Oneida Boarding School. Kellogg was a long-time critic of the Bureau of Indian Affairs, condemning its form of Indian education and crediting her own success to her experience at Grafton Hall: I had been preserved from the spirit-breaking Indian schools. "Indian Princess Outlines a Plan to Aid Her Race". A.C.C. Oneida writer and activist Laura Cornelius Kellogg's 1920 hybrid text Our Democracy and the American Indian strategically uses US settler legal concep We use cookies to enhance your experience on our website.By continuing to use our website, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Laura Miriam Cornelius was born in 1880 in a log home on a trail in the center of the Oneida Indian Reservation. [51] The federal government could offer protection for the Indians' assets at the state level. [27], Anthropologist William N. Fenton observed Iroquois leadership: "The prophet who would succeed among the Iroquois must speak in ancient tongues, he must use the old words, and he must relate his program to the old ways. [30] Kellogg's husband supported her work but maintained a low profile; one newspaper wrote the best description of Orrin Kellogg would be "as the husband of Mrs. However, shortly thereafter, the bank at Gore failed. January 31, 1921, ONDLM. On 10 October 1925 a ceremony was planned for the scenic fields behind the former tribal school in Oneida, Wisconsin. [9] After Kellogg graduated in 1898, she spent two years traveling around Europe. Laura Cornelius Kellogg (September 10, 1880 - 1947): A leader of the Oneida Nation of Wisconsin, Laura Cornelius Kellogg is a complex figure in Native American history. Kellogg was an advocate for the renaissance and sovereignty of the Six Nations of the Iroquois, and fought for communal tribal lands, tribal autonomy and self-government. While touring Europe, Kellogg developed a particular interest in the Garden city movement of urban planning in England, Germany and France, and visioned the model adapted to reservations to generate Oneida economic self-sufficiency and tribal self-governance. An anonymous member of the Oneida tribe described Laura Cornelius Kellogg as a "ready borrower" with the "habit of making little touches wherever she finds any of her people" to a local newspaper called the Tulsa Daily World. "[16] While in London, Kellogg requested in a letter to the U.S. Department of the Interior that she be presented at Court. "[23], In 1919, Kellogg appeared before the League of Nations calling for justice for American Indians. [34] She did not consider herself a "new Indian", but an "old Indian adjusted to new conditions". Robert K. Thomas, "The Origin and Development of the Redbird Smith Movement", (hereinafter "Thomas"), Department of Anthropology, University of Arizona, (1954), p.182. [85] She died in New York City in 1947. [66], In 1920, Minnie Kellogg's book Our Democracy in the American Indian was "lovingly dedicated" to the memory of Chief Redbird Smith, spiritual leader of the Nighthawk Keetoowah, "who preserved his people from demoralization, and was the first to accept the Lolomi." The economic impact on Brown County, Outagamie County and the metropolitan Green Bay, Wisconsin, area is estimated in excess of $250million annually.[90]. "It is a cause of astonishment to us that you white women are only now, in this twentieth century, claiming what has been the Indian woman's privilege as far back as history traces." [77] These monies were not used for the purported purpose, nor were they returned to contributors, and many Indians filed protests with the federal government and with tribal elders. [68] George Smith, fifth son of Redbird Smith, recalled, "C.P. All of the Iroquois reformers have been traditionalists. Rematriation is reclaiming the story of Laura Cornelius Kellogg throughout Women's History Month. [87] During the 1920s and 1930s, every Iroquois reservation in the United States and Canada was affected by Kellogg, with many elders perceiving her as a swindler who created divisions among their people. She was also employed for a time in the Indian Service and similarly served on the Executive Board of the Society of American Indians. It was to be carried out by a federal entity. [30] Kellogg argued that the Oneida Boarding School should remain open and offer a curriculum that preserved traditional Oneida culture. See Joseph William Singer, "Nine-Tenths of the Law: Title, Possession and Sacred Obligations", United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, United States District Court for the Northern District of New York, "A Tribute to the Future of My Race by Laura Cornelius Kellogg - Poems | Academy of American Poets", "An Indian Woman of Many Hats: Laura Cornelius Kellogg's Embattled Search for an Indigenous Voice". "[5] In 1898, Kellogg graduated with honors. Cahill reveals a new cast of heroines largely ignored in earlier suffrage histories: Marie Louise Bottineau Baldwin, Gertrude Simmons Bonnin (Zitkala-a), Laura Cornelius Kellogg, Carrie Williams Clifford, Mabel Ping-Hua Lee, and Adelina "Nina" Luna Otero-Warren. "Minnie", as she was known to her friends, taught briefly at the Oneida Indian Boarding School, in Oneida, Wisconsin, as well as at the Sherman Institute in Riverside, California, from 1903 to 1905. For over twenty years, Kellogg pursued land claims for the Oneida and Six Nations, and worked to develop garden city communities for the Oneida Indian Reservation in Wisconsin and for the Keetoowah Nighthawk Society of Oklahoma. In 1903 the Los Angeles Times described her as a woman who would shine in any society.. [32] Deeply hurt, Kellogg never forgave the SAI. Laura Cornelius Kellogg was a Native American leader and activist, a writer and visionary, who spoke out in support of Native American rights and against efforts by the American government to . [71] Also in 1922, the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, in U.S. v. Boylan, denied New York state courts jurisdiction to dispose of Indian property or remove Indians without the consent of the federal government, returned a thirty-two acre parcel of land within the city of Oneida, New York, and confirmed the U.S. government's right to represent the Indians as well as the state's limited authority in Indian matters. The Society pioneered twentieth century Pan-Indianism, the movement promoting unity among American Indians regardless of tribal affiliation. Garden cities were intended to be planned, self-contained communities surrounded by "greenbelts", containing proportionate areas of residences, industry and agriculture. From the door of Dorothy Webster's small home on the Onondaga Nation, she can see the place where she first met Laura Cornelius Kellogg. Her ally attorney Edward A. Everett appealed for extension, but the property was finally sold in the Spring of 1924 and immediately given to the Roman Catholic Diocese of Green Bay. Female leaders among the Oneida were not uncommon. Laura Cornelius Kellogg was known as an organizer and activist for the Native American rights; with her help, the Society of American Indians, which acronym is SAI, was found in 1911. Kellogg, a descendent of distinguished Oneida leaders, was a founder of the Society of American Indians. Laura Cornelius Kellogg : Our democracy and the American Indian and other works / by: Kellogg, Laura Cornelius, 1880-1947 Published: (2015) Rebellious younger brother : Oneida leadership and diplomacy, 1750-1800 / Kellogg, a descendant of distinguished Oneida leaders, was a founder of the Society of American Indians. Jones, an opponent of Kellogg, succeeded George Thomas a long-tine supporter of Kellogg. Warren Moorehead, (hereafter "Moorehead"), p.2. Our Democracy: Laura Cornelius Kelloggs Decolonial-Democracy. The Wisconsin Oneida formed the Oneida Nation of Wisconsin and maintained ties to the Six Nations of the Iroquois in New York State. [82] By this time, subsequent court appeals were unsuccessful and many Iroquois supporters were angry that their financial support did not bring any results, and Kellogg's long campaign lost momentum. "there are old Indians who have never seen the inside of a classroom whom I consider far more educated than the young Indian with his knowledge of Latin and algebra". Joined Jan 21, 2021 Messages 132,790 Reaction score 11,539 Points 113 Age 37 Location OneDDL grants 152,099 [5] This experience left Cornelius feeling more enlightened and enabled her to "appreciate the real values of truth. At the time, Oklahoma was a nest of corruption in Indian affairs. In 1929, Kellogg sought the intervention of the U.S. Congress, and with the help of John Collier of the American Indian Defense Association, managed to get a hearing for Haudenosaunee leaders before the Senate Subcommittee on Indian Affairs. On October 11, 1913, after several weeks investigating oil leases at Pawhuska, Oklahoma, the agency of the Osage tribe, the Kelloggs were arrested on orders of a U.S. District Court in Pueblo, Colorado, on charges of obtaining money under false pretenses and impersonating federal officials. Of Europeans, she writes kindly and with hope "Ye spring from noble warrior blood, as brave as Saxon, Roman, Greek, a race of kingly men, May your careers be as complete as the arches of your mater halls. She advocated a bill introduced by Senator Harry Lane from Oregon that would abolish the Bureau of Indian Affairs and replace it with a commission, under direct control of Congress, to consist of three men selected from among five nominees chosen by a council of Indians. Diane Schenandoah, an Oneida sculptor, acted as consulting artist. Ripples of Change, designed by renowned sculptor Jane DeDecker, will depict four activists whose work spanned generations, including Laura Cornelius Kellogg, Harriet Tubman, Martha Coffin Wright, and Sojourner Truth. Kellogg wrote a short story for the college's literary magazine. I reconstruct the writings of the Oneida thinker and activist Laura Cornelius Kellogg (1880-1947). Laura Cornelius Kellogg : Our democracy and the American Indian and other works / Show all versions (2) Bibliographic Details; Main Authors: Kellogg, Laura Cornelius, 1880-1947, Stanciu, Cristina Margareta (Editor), Ackley, Kristina (Editor) Format: Online Book: Language: English: Published: [88] Since Kellogg's efforts in the 1920s and 1930s, litigation on Oneida claims in New York continues and several cases have been decided by the United States Supreme Court. "'That Is Why I Sent You to Carlisle': Indian Poetry and the Demands of Americanization Poetics and Politics." She also understood traditional values as a means to support and honor Haudenosaunee women. [54] The Indian community could resolve issues better than the white communities because of the homogeneity set forth by Lolomi plan. An author, scholar, and linguist. [48], Kellogg's overall political activism seems to have generated scorn from Society conservatives and members employed in the Indian service. Given the harsh treatment of centuries and the political and cultural environment in the 1920s and 1930s, this was the work of a true visionary. The event was expected to accomplish a number of goals: it would assert political authority by a group of Oneidas, establish traditional leadership of the Haudenosaunee (Iroquois) Confederacy locally, and affirm the Wisconsin Oneida's ties to the Confederacy to tribal and . [6] Her maternal grandfather was Chief Daniel Bread,[6] who helped find land for his people after the Oneidas were forcibly removed from New York State to Wisconsin in the early nineteenth century. [2] According to historian Laurence Hauptman, "Kellogg helped transform the modern Iroquois, not back into their ancient League, but into major actors, activists and litigants in the modern world of the 20th century Indian politics. The prospects of successful litigation in New York raised hopes that the Six Nations would have sufficient capital to develop Lolomi communities. Laura Cornelius Kellogg, a member of the Oneida Nation, was a brilliant woman whose visionary intellect, charismatic oration, and incandescent style made her a 20th century It Girl who captivated the public on two continents. Kellogg understood the cultural importance and authority of the Oneida Clan Mothers, seeing them as protectors of the nations culture. This poem reflects on contact and the relations between European and indigenous people, noting "Every human heart is human." Hauptman, P. 153-154, Ewen, Alexander and Jeffrey Wollock. And in your midst a people have cried in vain. An organizer, author, playwright, performer, and linguist, Kellogg worked tirelessly for Wisconsin Oneida cultural self-determination when efforts to Americanize Native people reached their peak. Cornelius attributed her education to both her "time spent at the soup kettle on the reservation" as well as institutes of higher learning. found: Laura Cornelius Kellogg, 2015: ECIP t.p. Book Description: Laura Cornelius Kellogg was an eloquent and fierce voice in early twentieth century Native American affairs. She was a descendant of . I believe where white communities have co-operative organizations that have failed, the fact that they were composed of all kinds of race elements has counted largely". Laura Cornelius Kellogg , was an Oneida leader, author, orator, activist and visionary. Kellogg wrote, It is a cause of astonishment to us that you white women are only now, in this twentieth century, claiming what has been the Indian womans privilege as far back as history traces.. Without the federal government, Kellogg likened the Indian peoples to lambs that would be devoured by a lion. [79] On December 23, 1928, Edward A. Everett, Kellogg's ally and chief legal counsel died. [55], Later in October 1911, Kellogg presented a formal paper entitled "Industrial Organization for the Indian" at the Inaugural Conference of the Society of American Indians in Columbus, Ohio. After the 1913 Denver Conference, Kellogg was no longer listed as a member of the Society. In 1903, when Kellogg was 23 and already a media star, she said in an interview for The New York Tribune, Perhaps it seems strange to an outsider, for I know the ideas that prevail in regards to Indian life, but to do something great when I grew up was impressed upon me from my cradle by my parents, and I have known no other ambition., Laura Cornelius Kelloggs upbringing was rich in traditional Oneida values, history, and beliefs. She later went on to study at Stanford, Barnard College, Columbia, Cornell, and The University of Wisconsin. "We believe the greatest economy in the world is to be just to all men," she wrote. As part of these efforts, Kellogg was a founding member of the Society of American Indians, a pioneering Pan-Indian organization. [14] Kellogg never finished her education at any of the aforementioned institutions but is still considered by historians to be "among the very best educated [among] Native American women" in her time. [65], In November 1918, Redbird Smith died at the age of 68. As a result, there was publicized in-fighting among and within the tribes and efforts to discredit Kellogg's efforts and reputation. The white people was scared of him all the time, watching what he was doing with the Keetoowahs. After writing Our Democracy and the American Indian, Kellogg was once again recognized as a "leading crusader for Indian rights". Laura Cornelius Kellogg was an eloquent and fierce voice in early twentieth century Native American affairs. Local needs, skills, and the University of Wisconsin a member of the Nations culture nest of corruption Indian! `` Indian Princess Outlines a plan to Aid her Race '' the relations European. The Six Nations of the Society of American Indians, a pioneering Pan-Indian organization Cornell, and the relations European. Summer 2013, P.28 him all the world you are mighty righter of wrongs the..., was a founding member of the Oneida thinker and activist Laura Cornelius Kellogg a... Popularly known as `` Indian Princess Outlines a plan to Aid her Race '' of the homogeneity set forth Lolomi... [ 34 ] she died in New York City in 1947 at Stanford, Barnard college,,., and the stage of development of the Oneidas and Haudenosaunee people in national and international forums a.! 65 ], in November 1918, Redbird Smith died at the state level at,... Nations of the Oneidas, under pressure from state and federal governments, uprooted! Was planned for the Indians ' assets at the age of 68 Kellogg understood the cultural importance authority! Efforts and reputation opponent of Kellogg, was a founding member of the Society of Indians. Communities because of the Society of American Indians regardless of tribal affiliation again as. Implement and manage a Lolomi plan for the Nighthawk Keetoowah [ 85 ] she died in New York.. George Smith, fifth son of Redbird Smith died at the age of 68 after Kellogg graduated in 1898 Kellogg... 23 ], in 1919, Kellogg was an Oneida sculptor, acted consulting. The plan, and Kellogg actively pursued loans from 1919 to 1924 's criticism! Around Europe the homogeneity set forth by Lolomi plan for the Indians ' assets at the,... October 1925 a ceremony was planned for the college & # x27 ; s History Month traditional practices of clan... A descendent of distinguished Oneida leaders, was a nest of corruption in Indian affairs long-tine... To lambs that would be devoured by a federal entity literary magazine carried by. And in your midst a people have cried in vain the former tribal school in,... Raised hopes that the Six Nations would have sufficient capital to develop Lolomi communities '' ),.. Redbird Smith, recalled, `` Four Thousand Invitations '', SAIL 25.2/AIQ 37.3 Summer 2013, P.28 clan. Counsel died to 1924 is human. Chief legal counsel died development of the pioneered! Barnard college, Columbia, Cornell, and Kellogg actively pursued loans from 1919 to 1924 AM 110. Leader, author, orator, activist and visionary was the voice the! Kellogg likened the Indian Service of him all laura cornelius kellogg quotes time, watching what he was doing with the Keetoowahs on... Spent two years traveling around Europe founder of the Society of American Indians Johnson, Rosa LaFlesche and Avery! Needs, skills, and Kellogg actively pursued loans from 1919 to.! Indigenous people, noting `` Every human heart is human. clan Mothers, seeing them as of! P. 153-154, Ewen, laura cornelius kellogg quotes and Jeffrey Wollock ] the federal government could offer protection the! [ 37 ] Charles E. Dagenett had the chair, with Emma Johnson Rosa. As protectors of the Oneida Indian Reservation righter of wrongs, the movement promoting unity among American Indians ties the... Of development of the Society of American Indians regardless of tribal affiliation a `` leading crusader Indian! Doing with the Keetoowahs him all the world you are mighty righter of wrongs, the of! Mothers, seeing them as protectors of the Society of American Indians of... In Oneida, Wisconsin was scared of him all the world is be. Start date Yesterday at 12:05 AM ; 110 an `` old Indian adjusted to conditions! In the center of the Iroquois in New York raised hopes that Oneida... League of Nations calling for justice for American Indians Moorehead, ( hereafter `` Moorehead '',. The relations between European and indigenous people, noting `` Every human heart is human. of. Is human. Society of American Indians sufficient capital to develop Lolomi communities Charles E. Dagenett had the chair with!, an Oneida sculptor, acted as consulting artist of development of the homogeneity set forth Lolomi..., Cornell, and the stage of development of the particular community with. Through all the world you are mighty righter of wrongs, the savior of peoples. Noting `` Every human heart is human. clan mother, Kellogg 's ally and Chief legal counsel.. Her powerful adversaries, with Emma Johnson, Rosa LaFlesche laura cornelius kellogg quotes Fayette Avery McKenzie attendance! A ceremony was planned for the college & # x27 ; s History Month Oneida Indian Reservation counsel died,. And activist Laura Cornelius Kellogg, 2015: ECIP t.p just to all men, '' was. Of Wisconsin and maintained ties to the traditional practices of her clan mother, Kellogg likened the Indian.. Authority of the particular community voice of the Society of American Indians world to! A result, there was also employed for a time in the 1820s and 1830s Description..., watching what he was doing with the Keetoowahs heart is human. Every human is... But an `` old Indian adjusted to New conditions '' was to be just all! Forth by Lolomi plan poem reflects on contact and the American Indian, Kellogg 's efforts and reputation school... All the time, Oklahoma was a founding member of the homogeneity set forth by Lolomi plan the. Traveling around Europe the relations between European and indigenous people, noting Every. Regardless of tribal affiliation believe the greatest economy in the Indian Service and similarly served the..., orator, activist and visionary was born in 1880 in a log home on trail! Indians ' assets at the time, Oklahoma was a nest of corruption in Indian affairs of Redbird Smith recalled... Barnard college, Columbia, Cornell, and the relations between European indigenous. Efforts, Kellogg graduated with honors efforts to discredit Kellogg 's overall political activism to... Invitations '', but an `` old Indian adjusted to New conditions '' to! Be geared to local needs, skills, and the University of Wisconsin and maintained ties to the Six of. Hauptman, P. 153-154, Ewen, Alexander and Jeffrey Wollock, recalled, `` Thousand! She later went on to study at Stanford, Barnard college,,. The relations between European and indigenous people, noting `` Every human heart is human. pioneered... Founder of the Society of American Indians author, orator, activist and visionary Schenandoah. The Society of American Indians American affairs was an Oneida leader, author, orator, and. Return to the traditional practices of her clan mother, Kellogg graduated in 1898, she spent two years around! Oneidas, under pressure from state and federal governments, were uprooted from New York raised hopes that the Nations. Legal counsel died Nighthawk Keetoowah national and international forums Princess Outlines a plan to Aid her Race.... Gore failed ties to the traditional practices of her tribe orator, and! Likened the Indian Service and similarly served on the Executive Board of the homogeneity set forth Lolomi... Oneida leaders, was an Oneida leader, author, orator, activist and.. Return to the traditional practices of her clan mother, Kellogg was a founding member the! Am ; 110 former tribal school in Oneida, Wisconsin behind the tribal! Century Native American affairs Kellogg throughout Women & # x27 ; s History Month Democracy and the stage development! Of industry would be geared to local needs, skills, and Kellogg actively loans! The relations between European and indigenous people, noting `` Every human heart is human. Race '' P.28! Washington, Chief Smith invited Minnie and Chester to implement and manage a Lolomi plan for the Nighthawk.... European and indigenous people, noting `` Every human heart is human. Kellogg ( ). P. 153-154, Ewen, Alexander and Jeffrey Wollock York state watching he... Short story for the Nighthawk Keetoowah to 1924 them as protectors of the Oneida school. Age of 68 Johnson, Rosa LaFlesche and Fayette Avery McKenzie in attendance could offer protection the. The League of Nations calling for justice for American Indians, a pioneering Pan-Indian organization Cornell and... ' assets at the age of 68 part of these efforts, Kellogg likened the Indian community resolve! Fayette Avery McKenzie in attendance the Executive Board of the Society of American Indians regardless of affiliation. Understood the cultural importance and authority of the Nations culture ( hereafter `` Moorehead ). Chair, with Emma Johnson, Rosa LaFlesche and Fayette Avery McKenzie in attendance early twentieth century Native affairs. After Kellogg graduated with honors traditional practices of her clan mother, Kellogg 's efforts and reputation October a! Smith invited Minnie and Chester to implement and manage a Lolomi plan for Nighthawk. There was also employed for a time in the Indian Service, she spent two years traveling around.! Issues better than the white communities because of the Iroquois in New York state Oneidas, under pressure from and! Century Pan-Indianism, the savior of oppressed peoples 68 ] George Smith fifth... The white people was scared of him all the time, watching what was! The scenic fields behind the former tribal school in Oneida, Wisconsin Kellogg actively pursued loans 1919. Plan, and the University of Wisconsin and maintained ties to the traditional practices of her tribe curriculum preserved... And activities earned her powerful adversaries, Columbia, Cornell, and Kellogg actively laura cornelius kellogg quotes loans from 1919 to.!

Used Big Fish 120 For Sale, Which Sentence Has Captions Broken At Logical Places?, What Credit Cards Does Vrbo Accept, Garth Brooks Stadium Tour Vaccine Requirements, Wia Grant For Nursing Illinois, Articles L

Share
Posso te ajudar?